Vale of Leven F.C.

One part of the the foundation story of Vale of Leven F.C. is that it was formed in August 1872 but as team that was unsure whether it would play Association or Rugby-football. Another part is that Queen's Park F.C. in the summer or autumn of that same year took the train to Alexandria to put on at Park Neuk in the town a game, a demonstration game, which atracted the attention not just of local sportsmen but from the whole of the Leven valley. What is certain is that by 21st December 1872 and just three weeks after the first Scotland-England had been played at Hamiton Crescent in Partick the decision had been made. "The Vale" was a round-ball club, would itself travel to Glasgow to play Queen's Park away and would receive the same club just three weeks later at home. The die had been cast but not just in terms of the future of the sport itself but in the way in Scotland it would soon be played but how the Vale of Leven would change the direction of the game. In a match against Airdrie at the end of August 1872 Queen's Park had adopted a new 2-2-6 on-field formation. It had used that same formation in the international but in between and for the rest of the 1872-3 season reverted to the English 1-2-7. However, The Vale not only had also employed 2-2-6, what would become recognised as "the Scottish formation", in the December game but would not stray from it, albeit in one form or another, for the next decade and a half of unparalleled success at club level - the World's first trophy-winning working-class team, three Scottish Cup wins in a row, four times runner-up, "World Champions" - and for the national team - one defeat in fifteen seasons.
Internationalists
Sandy McLintock Jack C. Baird John McGregor
John McDougall Andy McIntyre Jack McPherson
Bobby Paton Alick Barbour Jim Wilson
Archie McCall Dan Bruce Will McColl
Dan Paton Andy Whitelaw Willie MIlls
Robert Parlane Sandy Kennedy Jimmy (& John) Cowan
John Ferguson Johnny Forbes Jimmy McAulay
Neilly McCallum Willie McKinnon James McMillan
Gil Rankin Johnny Browning Snr. John Murray
John (& Duncan & William) Ritchie
Other Top-Flight Players
W. C. Wood Archie Michie Johnny McFarlane
Peter McGregor Will Jamieson James Baird
David Lindsay Malcolm McVean Dan Friel
Johnny Darroch (Bob McDermid) Jimmy Moir
James McLachlan Robert McRae John Cust
James Fleming John Walker John Browning Jnr.
Tommy Galbraith Alex Paton Robert McRae
James Sharp James McIntyre John Baird
Walter Bruce Archie Osborne Jimmy Robertson
John & Robert McLean John & Duncan McNichol
___________________________________________
Renton F.C.

It is said that Renton F.C., or at least it first iteration was also formed on 31st May 1872 but there is no on-field confirmation. It was not, unlike The Vale, a founder member in March 1873 of the Scottish Football Association but it did play a first fixture in October of that same year in the first playing of the Scottish Cup; a 2-0 win over Kilmarnock in the First Round. In fact it would only lose and to Queen's Park in the December semi-final of that first competition, a 2-0 loss away which already made it on paper the third best team in the country. Moreover, the following season it would even go a step further, reaching the final only lose again to Queen's Park, this time 3-0 but once more away and with two of the goals conceded in the last fifteen minutes.
But after that this version of Renton would gradually fade, although making the last eight in 1878-9. In 1879-8 it lost heavily to Dumbarton at home in the Second Round. In 1879-80 there was a repeat away, in 1880-81 home defeat, this time to The Vale and in 1881-2 it allowed a First Round walkover, seemingly unable to raise an eleven, and then resigned from the SFA and thus the competition.
Yet this was not the end. Football did not die but was taken on by and an almost secret club, Renton Wanderers, its matches reported in the local Press but seemingly not affiliated to the SFA. And from it for the 1882-3 season a new Renton F.C. rose and it was within five years not just to sweep all before it but be the creator and vehicle for literally the sport's next on-field game-changer, perhaps its greatest ever, home and abroad.
Internationalists
Andrew Hannah Alick Barbour Harry Campbell
Neilly McCallum Will McColl Matthew Dickie
James McCall John Lindsay Johnny Murray
Duncan McLean Jack Baird Archie McCall
Donald Colman Bob Glen Alex Jackson
James Kelly Bob Kelso Tom Kelso
John (& Duncan & William) Ritchie Joe Lindsay
Other Top-Flight Players
James Kelso Walter Bruce Jack Pryce
William McKennie Alex Brady Joe Brady
Johnny Darroch Bob McDermid Tommy Galbraith
John Cameron David Hannah John Bell
Jack McNee Jimmy Brown Frank Dyer
Donald McKechnie James McBride George Campbell
Robert Johnston(e) Patrick Gordon Thomas Towie
Billy Fraser John Crawford Duncan Ritchie
Willie Ritchie Billy Fleming John Harvey(ie)
Tom Vallance Johnny Campbell David Gilfillan
Robert Duncan & David Tait A. McIntyre and Alex
GrantHarry Gardiner James Brown William McKennie
___________________________________________
Dumbarton F.C.

Dumbarton F.C. has its foundation date as 23rd December 1872, which may well be true but the club was not amongst those to have formed the Scottish Football Association in March 1873. However, it was there when the Scottish Cup kicked off the following November.
It then continued for the best part of a decade somewhat in the shadow of Renton and Vale of Leven before emerging from 1880 in its own right as a major competitive force for the next dozen years. In part the reason was population. It increased over the two decades by about a half, matching the rest of the Vale. And that swelling produced not just new locally-honed talent but also the creation of additional senior clubs. Between 1880 and 1882 the number went from three to seven. Then by 1887, whilst two had gone four more had been formed. And Dumbarton F.C. itself was to have a series of stable teams that by 1891 and the formation of the Scottish League enabled the club to be champions in both the first two seasons.
And it would be from the the 1886-7 and 1888-89 team that Johnny Madden would come, not just initially as a professional in England with Gainsborough and Grimsby, then for six seasons with Celtic but from 1905 the first permanently to take abroad the Vale of Leven's game, by then that played in Scotland and very widely in England. That year he moved to Prague, then in the Austro-Hungarian Empire to coach Slavia. And he never came back. He remained with the club for the next quarter of a century, also coaching the Bohemian and Czecho-Slovak national teams. Moreover, he would die, still in the Czech capital, in 1946 and remains there a figure of reverence.
Internationalists
Tom Kelso Alex Jackson Archie Lang
Joe Lindsay Peter Miller Jimmy McAulay
Willie Mckinnon Bob Kelso Hugh Wilson
Leitch Keir Ralph Aitken Tom McMillan
William Robertson John McLeod Finlay Speedie
Johnny Browning Snr. Jack (& Lawrence) Bell
Robert "Sparrow" Brown Geordie Dewar
Jack Fraser Bobby Howe Alex Latta
Robert "Plumber" Brown Johnny Madden
Jacky Robertson Jack Taylor Willie Thomson
Michael Paton Duncan Stewart Harry Chatton
Other Top-Flight Players
Daniel Watson Alex Miller John McNichol
Dickie Boyle Hugh Mair James McNaught
James Stevenson James Galbraith Jock Hutcheson
Robert Johnston(e) Ronald Cameron John Gra(i)nger
Bob Ferrier Snr. Bob Ferrier Jnr. Thomas Towie
James Hartley Lawrence Bell Alf Smith
Abe Hartley Jimmy Weir John Docherty
___________________________________________